Conversations with Krishnamurti 1/5
Jan 01, 1999 11:39 AM
by M K Ramadoss
In response to posting an excerpt on CWL's clairvoyance, some questions
were raised. I am posting the five part msg from which I excerpted the
passage.
mkr
=========
Hi Rob, I'd like to follow your example and post a K text. I got it
from David Walker who gathered together a small e-mail group of people
interested in k. He mailed it to us in five discrete segments. I'll do
the same. I don't know enough about computers to do it otherwise.
Regards, Hermann
David Walker wrote:
Dear Friends,
This is the first piece by Dr. Ruben Feldman-Gonzalez recalling
his dialogues with Krishnamurti.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
P R O L O G U E
During my encounters with people many asked me to write of my
dialogues with Krishnamurti, even knowing I would be retrieving
them only from my memory since only a few had been recorded.
So it was that I started to think of writing some of my memories
down.
Nevertheless, some other friends felt that it was unnecessary to
write my memories since Krishnamurti had done such a beautiful work
of exposition of life and truth for mankind with his own books,
videos and audiotapes.
I hope that anyone who reads "My Dialogues with Krishnamurti" feels
the need to read Krishnamurti himself.
I have almost stopped reading, and if I do it is only to read
"Krishnamurti Journals" or "Commentaries On Living" by Krishnamurti
and "Collected Works of Krishnamurti" (17 volumes Kendall-Hunt)
(1933-1967).
Looking For The North
Political contradiction in Argentina was always high.
It came to one of its highest points, though, by the end of August
1972.
During this time a group of leftist, guerrilla men and women were
killed while in jail at Trelew-Argentina, and I was horrified to
hear that one of them had been a friend of the family.
I started to get phone calls prompting me to take sides in the
armed struggle: "If you are not for the left you are for the
right", a man's voice had told me on the phone before he hung-up
while I was taking care of a recently born baby in Villada,
Argentina, Aug. 23rd 1972.
The following day I went to Buenos Aires to get a visa to the
U.S.A. (1972).
If man looses respect for life we are all at risk from each other.
Man becomes his own executioner.
Only after two years I got a temporary visa to enter the U.S.A.
Every Argentinian was suspicious then.
I stopped over in Puerto Rico. There was a man there I wanted to
meet: Enrique Biascoechea.
I did meet him. He was dying. He had been a friend of Krishnamurti
since age nine.
He wrote a letter to Krishnamurti telling him that I had left
behind my parents, two baby sons, possessions, friends, profession,
comfort, and status in order to travel to meet with him.
That was in June 1974. Enrique died in Nov 1974.
After reaching the U.S. I soon found myself working 16 hours a day
as a resident physician in Pennsylvania. I needed a dictionary to
dictate my notes. Of the other eight hours of the day I spent four
in the basement to study medicine in English to revalidate my
license. I slept three or four hours a day and ate only once a day,
taking coffee in the morning and again at lunchtime simply to keep
myself awake.
Sometimes I wondered how my body could bear so much abuse!
I got letters from Argentina: "Misery. My family and my friends
kept disappearing".
I had given up hope to meet Krishnamurti when I got a letter from
Mrs. Zimbalist, dated Jan. 5th 1975 in Ojai, California telling me
I had a personal interview with Krishnamurti on march 23rd at 4
P.M. at the Huntington Hotel in San Francisco, California.
Mrs. Zimbalist volunteered her time for Krishnamurti as a devoted
secretary. She is the widow of the late Sam Zimbalist who had
produced the reknowned film "Ben Hur".
At four P.M. on March 23rd 1975 sharp I knocked at Krishnamurti's
door. Mrs. Zimbalist did everything to make me feel comfortable.
Krishnmurti came after five minutes. I stood up from the armchair
to shake his hand. He looked smaller than I expected him to be. He
wore an old blue jacket. He sat in front of me with nothing in
between the two chairs. Mrs. Zimbalist left silently.
We sat there looking at each other. I will never be able to
describe that moment when Krishnmurti was gazing at me.
I felt at the same time all the love I had felt for my parents, my
sons, my girlfriends, my friends (dead or alive)...
There was long silence.
Krishnamurti said: Biascoechea says you are ready to work for the
Foundation.
I said: I may not be wise or free enough for that.
Krishnamurti: You will.
Ruben: What would the work imply?
Krishnamurti: Publishing books, videos and tapes.
Ruben: That implies managing money.
Krishnamurti: Millions of dollars.
Ruben: That horrifies me. I'm not ready for that. I thought
I would have to travel with you, type your lectures
from recorded tapes.... things like that.
Krishnamurti: (Laughing) You can do more than that Dr...
Ruben: My name is Ruben Ernesto Feldman-Gonzalez.
Krishnamurti: That's confusing, may I call you Dr. Gonzalez?
Ruben: Of course, but my real name is Anger.
Krishnamurti: (touching my left knee) Ah! I'm glad you don't wear
a mask like so many that come to me pretending to be
saints.
Ruben: I'm far from that. I feel a complete repugnance for
the so-called political situation of Argentina, my
country of birth, and even for the way my profession
is practiced. I'm a pediatric surgeon. I had started
to study psychiatry (July 1974) in Pennsylvania to
see why the world has gone so crazy. Nevertheless I'm
not impressed, the approach to treatment in
psychiatry is conventional... standardized. I'll
leave psychiatry too. I don't know what I will do.
Krishnamurti: Don't leave psychiatry. Change it.
Ruben: I never thought you would give me concrete advice
like that. It sounds absurd though. Changing
psychiatry sounds like changing the color of the
crickets of the world.
Krishnamurti: You have to change psychiatry.
Ruben: I wish I knew what you meant.
Krishnamurti: You have to meet Dr. David Bohm in London. Let's go
there soon.
Ruben: I wish I could, perhaps if I get a loan.
Krishnamurti: No! Don't ask for a loan. You'll meet him soon
anyway.
Ruben: I need to make changes. I have no peace. Friends have
disappeared in Argentina. Everything seems so chaotic
and corrupt....
Krishnamurti: (smiling) You need exercise (Krishnamurti touched my
belly with the tip of his left index finger).
Ruben: I work 16 hours a day and then I have to sit to study
for four hours a day before I go to sleep. All this
to renew my medical license in the USA.
Krishnamurti: That's an excuse. Take care of yourself. You need
exercise. You look like a bull.
Ruben: Sometimes I feel that I need to share my
understanding with people around the world. What do
you say to that?
Krishnamurti: You speak.
A very long silence followed. I had expected him to tell me to
"stay put" and spend the rest of my life in silent meditation. With
very few words he was the perfect mirror for my own contradictions
to emerge and be clearly seen.
He insisted: The Foundation in Puerto Rico has no head. I hope
you will take it (he grabbed my left knee).
Ruben: Krishnaji, when I was with Biascoechea everything
seemed so easy. Now I see I don't have the peace of
mind, the right skills nor the freedom (the sons and
two parents to feed) to dedicate myself sensibly to
such an important and difficult task. It is certainly
no picnic.
Krishnamurti: I hope you take it.
Another long silence followed.
Krishnamurti discussed several items regarding the Foundation's
translations, people like Salvado Sendra, Vimala Thakar, personal
and ideological struggles within the Foundations, etc.
Ruben: I'm eager to meet Salvador and Vimala... but people
from the Fourth Path are trying to mix what you say
with what others have said and are quite willing to
control the Foundations.
Krishnamurti: That has been going on all the time and not only with
them. The Fourth Path is a path of violence which
reinforces the ego and the wish to control life and
its course. Do not touch it. The first insight is to
drop everything non-essential for the total
liberation of mankind.
Ruben: Now that you mention the non-essential.... Why did
you allow the biography of yours written by Lutyens
to be published? It's gossipy and superficial, and it
may not be right selling "At the Feet of the Master"
... with your name on it.
Krishnamurti: Not my books.
Ruben: And they are making a profit.
Krishnamurti: It's not my business.
Ruben: How would you recommend your books to be read, and
in what order?
Krishnamurti: Do not read them like a novel. Read slowly as if your
life was in every word and every sentence. Start with
the last one and then if there is an interest go
backwards through the first one.
Ruben: Should we read all your books?
Krishnamurti: If you take a train in San Francisco to go to Los
Angeles... would you get off in Santa Barabara?
We both laughed. One had to laugh very often in the company of
Krishnamurti. Today the order of the books would be:
"Ending of Time"
"The Awakening of Intelligence"
"Commentaries on Living"
"Journal"
"Freedom from the Known", etc.
"Collected Works" (1933-67)
I asked: Why don't you eat meat?
He answered: Pity.
I expected a longer lecture but that was all he said. Again a long
silence. The silence was alive, the silence of two alert friends
seeing together the same thing at the same time.
He stood up and said. "Excuse me Dr. Gonzalez, I'll prepare some
tea for you".
At the kitchen in the big suite he whispered something with Mrs.
Zimbalist who was sitting there.
He came back with a cup of tea. He said: "Tea of roses for you".
I sipped it, but I didn't like it. I left it on the little table
beside us.
Ruben: Can we talk about meditation?
Krishnamurti: Is there anything else?
Ruben: Well, the very word meditation is used by gurus of
all kinds to make money, sell silly books,
techniques, pillows, crystals, mantras, and incense.
Krishnamurti: I have been using the word for 50 years. I can't
change it now. People will have to see I use the word
with a different meaning. I do not use the word
meditation with its traditional meaning!
Ruben: What about using the expression "Unitary Perception"
instead.
Krishnamurti: You use it.
(Krishnamurti said he would not use the word meditation anymore
during his last talk in England in 1985, ten years later.)
Krishnamurti: Why not live very simply?
Call it meditation or Unitary Perception.
Self protection and self aggrandizement through money
making and success have to end in order to live
simply. To live simply is to live intelligently,
without an observer in observation. If you believe
you have to go back to Argentina to be loyal to some
concept of yours you are not simple. If you are angry
you are not simple. If you are full of sorrow you
can't love anyone. Can you be spontaneous and simply
act with not too much planning?
Ruben: You are not saying I have to remain alone and live in
poverty and silence.
Krishnamurti: Would that be simple?
Would you be escaping from life?
The consummation of truth is not to be successful or
wealthy... but do you want complete truth?
Look for success or money and you'll find
frustration. Look for truth and you'll receive total
peace of mind and joy. Will you be one of the few? Or
will you continue being one of the many worshippers
of money and success?
After a long silence, he said: "Dr. Gonzalez, your tea must be cold
already, finish it!"
I didn't have the courage to say no and I did finish it silently.
He said: "Let's meet tomorrow at eight A.M.
Krishnamurti went with me to the door, opened it for me and smiled
lovingly saying: "Good bye".
I said: What noun should be applied to what you teach--
"message", "gospel",..., or what?
Krishnamurti said: Call it "the teachings". Let's meet tomorrow
at eight A.M., right here.
I spend the rest of the afternoon by myself in my room, which I had
rented at the same hotel where Krishnamurti was staying.
I felt like a Condor for the rest of the day.
I met Krishnamurti by chance in the lobby that evening. I walked
with him for awhile.
I saw a couple of very beautiful girls.
I said: "God, how beautiful they are".
He said: "Only well fed".
I said: "Krishnaji, I felt like a Condor the whole afternoon, full
of peace and joy and love. I think it's because I spent some time
with you."
Krishnamurti said: "For how long do you want to be infected?"
-
[Back to Top]
Theosophy World:
Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application